the speaking
Monday, November 16, 2009 at 01:09PM The speaking thing went well enough, I suppose. I certainly could have been more eloquent. It was round-robin style, so I didn't write out a speech or anything like that; I jotted some notes on each of the themes and went from there. It's hard to think while keeping one eye out on the baby, although a couple of folks I knew in the audience helped, too. (Predictably, the girl cried when the very nice mom of one of Thing Two's classmates tried to touch her. She's very friendly, the girl, but only on her own terms.) Also, Thing One did a great job of watching her and playing with her and following her around whenever she decided to explore. I was very proud of him.
I don't really think of myself as a birthing advocate, so it was odd to find myself on a panel like that. (The topic of the forum--I referenced this in the last post, but in case you missed that post--was "When Birth Doesn't Go As Planned.") My second child was born via emergency c-section at 34 weeks. Definitely, nobody plans that. I made my peace with my c-sections a while ago, but there were two points I wanted to get across to those in the audience who are in the field of supporting pregnant and postpartum women.
First, that birth was traumatic for me, not necessarily because it ended surgically but because I had an abruption that wasn't even discovered until the baby was delivered. An abruption is an OB emergency, and babies can and do die from it. This haunted me. The baby was absolutely fine. It's a rare 34-week baby who doesn't spend any time at all in a NICU, but that was us. As I said last night, there are no support groups for women who have had a traumatic birth and the baby was just fine. It sounds like there are some more local resources than there were five years ago, but my main point was that nobody but nobody was monitoring my emotional health. The baby was fine! What could possibly be wrong? Well, nothing, except that I was convinced that Death had been on that maternity floor and we had gotten away with something--our baby was fine. I was fine. And Death was lurking around, waiting for me to screw up--take an unnecessary car ride, for instance--so he could take my baby via a horrific car accident. Oh, that just sounds crazy, doesn't it? That's sort of my point. I eventually got through the crazy, but wouldn't it have been better to have had some help with that? It's shocking how many OBs and midwives don't check up on their patients' postpartum emotional health.
(An aside: After my first baby was born, I had insomnia and my OCD tendencies really stepped it up, and at my six-week postpartum check-up I told my midwife I was having trouble sleeping so I was up at 5:30 am to wash the floor because it was just too dirty with a baby in the house, and this tripped no alarms whatsoever. I think it should have.)
The second point I wanted to make is that all births are natural births. There is an implied hierarchy of birth when we speak of natural birth versus any other type of birth. Is it no longer natural if a woman has an epidural? What about a c-section? This word bothers me a lot when it is applied to activities like birthing and parenting. "Natural parenting" sounds so pretentious, so superior. Am I unnatural if I decide I'm done with cloth diapers? Is it unnatural to use formula? Does it make you less of a mother? Does it make me less of a mother because I had two c-sections? No, of course not.
I don't refer to my first birth (drug-free, in a birthing center) as "natural." That's my intervention-free birth. I see my next two births as incorporating the most extreme birthing intervention, surgery. But the two participants--me and the baby--we're both natural, thank you very much. We had some extra help. That extra help saved lives. The goal is a live, healthy baby. When we speak of natural birth, we set up the expectation for (some) women that that is the correct way to give birth, and all other experiences fall short. There are certain magazines I no longer read, certain places I don't frequent, because this attitude aggravates me so much. There is no one right way to give birth, or to be a parent. There are many ways to reach the intended, hoped-for result.
For me, the absolute star of this panel was the woman who had struggled with debilitating postpartum depression and anxiety after the birth of her first baby. After the birth of her second, she made the conscious decision to use formula rather than to breastfeed, because she knew lack of sleep was a trigger for her depression to return, and because she wanted to take her meds. She said her children needed a balanced, functioning mother far more than the baby needed breast milk over formula. I felt like applauding her. In so many ways, mothers, especially, put themselves last, and in doing so, we're not allowing ourselves to be the best mother for our children. How wise of her, how absolutely smart and right, for her to tell the lactation consultant to take the pump away and bring in the formula.
When I was pregnant for the first time I was pretty committed to breastfeeding, but I remember reading a post in a forum for first-time mothers written by a woman with MS who wouldn't be breastfeeding because she would need to go back on the MS meds as soon as she gave birth, and I thought, That makes complete sense. And also, I'm glad I don't have to make that choice. I admit to being a huge breastfeeding advocate. I don't understand why, in the absence of medical reasons (which include needing medications that are contraindicated while breastfeeding) someone wouldn't even try. I cherish the nursing relationship I have/had with each of my children. But when someone is feeding their child a bottle out in public, it is not my place--or anyone else's--to comment on it. I have witnessed some shocking condescension towards mothers who bottle feed, both in person and online, and I just have to quote my sister here. Some people have no idea what's not their business.
So. That's how the speaking went. I probably could have done better. I'm pretty much at peace with each of my births, because look! Look at those beautiful kids! An embarrassment of riches, is what they are, no matter how they got here or what I went through to deliver them into the world.
(We'll be back to our normal crafty-type stuff in the next post, assuming my kids ever attend a full day of school again. Thing Two didn't even go today, and Thing One was sent home early because he was coughing too much; he just woke up from a nap.)
amy |
10 Comments | 












